ECONOMIC RELIEF: The CARES Act

The most significant piece of legislation Congress has passed to address the coronavirus pandemic impact was
H.Res.748, the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act, described as "the largest rescue package in American history," which President Trump signed into law on March 27, 2020.  The bill has a price tag of around $2 trillion. 

Provisions of the act included funds to help hard-hit industries, loans for small businesses, direct cash payments for citizens earning less than $99,000, expanded unemployment benefits, funds for hospitals, funds for states and municipalities, funds for the airline industry and funds for FEMA.  The act also established a Pandemic Response Accountability Committee and a Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery to provide a measure of oversight.  Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said the CARES Act provided "big help and quick help." 

As the press releases below show, the path to the agreement was rather bumpy.  The original CARES Act (S.3548), introduced by Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, underwent major changes until, in the early hours of March 25, negotiators led by McConnell, Schumer and Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin, reached agreement Late on March 25 the Senate passed the bill by a vote of 96-0.  On March 27, the House  passed the legislation on a voice vote.  President Trump signed the bill that afternoon.  The legislation came at the right time; on March 26 the U.S. Department of Labor reported a record 3.28 million people filed for unemployment benefits in the week of March 21. 

See also:
Jesse Drucker.  "Bonanza for Rich Real Estate Investors, Tucked Into Stimulus Package."  New York Times, March 26, 2020.

Jeff Stein.  "Tax change in coronavirus package overwhelmingly benefits millionaires, congressional body finds."  Washington Post, April 14, 2020.


Donald J. Trump for President, Inc.
March 27, 2020

Trump campaign statement on President Trump’s signing of the CARES Act 

“Americans can see that President Trump is out front and leading the country in the battle against the coronavirus. With his signing of the CARES Act, Americans will get the relief they need as they fight through this crisis. President Trump is both protecting the health and safety of our citizens and safeguarding our economy at the same time.”

- Brad Parscale, Trump 2020 campaign manager

Republican National Committee
March 27, 2020
email from Steve Guest.  subject: Trump's winning leadership

President Trump’s leadership in the face of coronavirus has delivered much needed relief that will help millions of Americans.
 
Despite the relentless attacks from Democrats and the media, a strong majority of America is behind President Trump’s leadership during the coronavirus pandemic.
 
  • ABC/Washington Post poll: 66% express confidence in the federal government’s ability to handle the outbreak.
  • Gallup poll: 60% approve of the President’s response to the coronavirus. The Gallup poll also showed an increase in the President’s approval rating among independents and Democrats.
  • Hill-Harris poll: 61% of voters say President Trump is taking strong measures to slow or stop coronavirus spread.
  • ABC/Ipsos poll: 55% approve of the President’s management of the crisis.
  • CBS News poll: 53% say the President is doing a good job of handling the outbreak.
 
Bottom Line: By signing the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act into law, President Trump is keeping his promise to fight for every American and to always keep America First.
The White House
  Issued on: March 27, 2020

Statement by the President

Today, I have signed into law H.R. 748, the “Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act” or the “CARES” Act (the “Act”).  The Act makes emergency supplemental appropriations and other changes to law to help the Nation respond to the coronavirus outbreak.  I note, however, that the Act includes several provisions that raise constitutional concerns.

Section 15010(c)(3)(B) of Division B of the Act purports to require the Chairperson of the Council of the Inspectors General on Integrity and Efficiency to consult with members of the Congress regarding the selection of the Executive Director and Deputy Executive Director for the newly formed Pandemic Response Accountability Committee.  The Committee is an executive branch entity charged with conducting and coordinating oversight of the Federal Government’s response to the coronavirus outbreak.  I anticipate that the Chairperson will be able to consult with members of the Congress with respect to these hiring decisions and will welcome their input.  But a requirement to consult with the Congress regarding executive decision-making, including with respect to the President’s Article II authority to oversee executive branch operations, violates the separation of powers by intruding upon the President’s power and duty to supervise the staffing of the executive branch under Article II, section 1 (vesting the President with the “executive Power”) and Article II, section 3 (instructing the President to “take Care” that the laws are faithfully executed).  Accordingly, my Administration will treat this provision as hortatory but not mandatory.

Section 4018 of Division A of the Act establishes a new Special Inspector General for Pandemic Recovery (SIGPR) within the Department of the Treasury to manage audits and investigations of loans and investments made by the Secretary of the Treasury under the Act.  Section 4018(e)(4)(B) of the Act authorizes the SIGPR to request information from other government agencies and requires the SIGPR to report to the Congress “without delay” any refusal of such a request that “in the judgment of the Special Inspector General” is unreasonable.  I do not understand, and my Administration will not treat, this provision as permitting the SIGPR to issue reports to the Congress without the presidential supervision required by the Take Care Clause, Article II, section 3.

Certain other provisions (such as sections 20001, 21007, and 21010 of Division B of the Act) purport to condition the authority of officers to spend or reallocate funds upon consultation with, or the approval of, one or more congressional committees.  These provisions are impermissible forms of congressional aggrandizement with respect to the execution of the laws.  The Congress may affect the execution of the laws only by enacting a new statute in accordance with the requirements of bicameralism and presentment prescribed in Article I, section 7.  My Administration will make appropriate efforts to notify the relevant committees before taking the specified actions and will accord the recommendations of such committees all appropriate and serious consideration, but it will not treat spending decisions as dependent on prior consultation with or the approval of congressional committees.

Finally, several provisions (such as sections 3511(d)(4) and 3862 (creating section 744N(d)(1) of the Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act) of Division A of the Act) purport to require recommendations regarding legislation to the Congress.  Because Article II, section 3 gives the President the authority to recommend only “such Measures as he shall judge necessary and expedient,” my Administration will continue the practice of treating provisions like these as advisory and non-binding.

DONALD J. TRUMP

THE WHITE HOUSE,
March 27, 2020.


March 27, 2020

Remarks by President Trump at Signing of H.R.748, The CARES Act

Oval Office

4:10 P.M. EDT
THE PRESIDENT:  Well, thank you all very much.  This is a very important day.  I’ll sign the single-biggest economic relief package in American history and, I must say, or any other package, by the way.  It’s twice as large as any relief ever signed.  It’s $2.2 billion, but it actually goes up to 6.2 — potentially — billion dollars — trillion dollars.  So you’re talking about 6.2 trillion-dollar bill.  Nothing like that.  And this will deliver urgently needed relief to our nation’s families, workers, and businesses.  And that’s what this is all about.

And it got a 96 to nothing.  And, I don’t know, what was the number in Congress?

PARTICIPANT:  A voice vote.

THE PRESIDENT:  A voice?  It was fantastic.

PARTICIPANT:  I think it was just as close.

THE PRESIDENT:  That’s pretty amazing.  That’s about the same thing.  Right, Kevin?

LEADER MCCARTHY:  Yes.

THE PRESIDENT:  So, that’s fantastic.  But I want to thank Republicans and Democrats for coming together, setting aside their differences, and putting America first.

This legislation provides for direct payments to individuals and unprecedented support to small businesses.  We’re going to keep our small businesses strong and our big businesses strong.  And that’s keeping our country strong and our jobs strong.

This historic bill includes the following:

  • $300 billion in direct cash payments will be available to every American citizen earning less than $99,000 per year; $3,400 for a typical family of four.  So a family of four: $3,400.
  • And then $350 billion in job retention loans for small businesses, with loan forgiveness available for businesses that continue paying their workers.  The workers get paid.
  • Approximately $250 billion in expanded unemployment benefits.  The average worker who has lost his or her job will receive 100 percent of their salary for up to four full months.
So, things like this have never happened in our country.

  • $500 billion in support for hard-hit industries, with a ban on corporate stock buybacks — we don’t let them buy back the stock; we don’t let that happen — and tough limits on executive compensation.
  • Over $100 billion to support our heroic doctors, nurses, and hospitals.  And you see what’s happening.  And I want to thank, while we’re here, also the incredible job that’s done by the Army Corps of Engineers and by FEMA.  It’s been incredible.  They did four hospitals in two days or three days, in New York.  And they’re, like, incredible structures.  What a job they’ve been doing.  And they’re doing them all over the country.
  • $45 billion for the Disaster Relief Fund, supporting our state, local, and tribal leaders.
  • $27 billion for the development of vaccines, therapies, and other public health response efforts, including $16 billion to build up the Strategic National Stockpile with critical stockpiles.  And I’m going to — we have tremendous supplies coming into the stockpile, and you’ll be seeing that and hearing about it in a little bit because we’re doing a news conference at 5:30 on what’s happening.
We’ve had tremendous results on the respirators.  We’ve had great results on just about everything we’re talking about.  Boeing just announced that they’re going to be making the plastic field shields — the actual shields, which are hard to come by, and they’re going to be making them by the thousands a week.

And the ventilators, which is probably the most difficult because it’s like — it’s like building a car — we will be announcing thousands of — are going to be built and we have them under contract and we have fast deliveries.  As you know, we delivered thousands to New York.  And unfortunately — they were delivered to a warehouse, which was good — unfortunately, they didn’t take them, but now they’re taking them.  New York is now taking them and redistributing them around the areas that they need.

So you have also $3.5 billion to states to expand childcare benefits for healthcare workers, first responders, and others on the frontlines of this crisis, and $1 billion for securing supplies under the Defense Protection Act.  And, as you know, I’ve enacted the act.  We’ve used it three or four times.  I pulled it back three times because the companies came through, in the end.  They didn’t need the act.  It’s been great leverage.

I have instituted it against General Electric.  We thought we had a deal for 40,000 ventilators and, all of the sudden, the 40,000 came down to 6,000.  And then they talked about a higher price than we were discussing, so I didn’t like it.  So we did — we did activate it, with respect to General Motors.  And hopefully, maybe we won’t even need the full activation.  We’ll find out.  But we need the ventilators.

I said hello today — I called him — a wonderful guy, Boris Johnson.  As you know, he tested positive.  And before he even said hello, he said, “We need ventilators.”  I said, “Wow.  That’s a big statement.”  And hopefully, he’s going to be in good shape.

I just spoke to Angela Merkel, and she’s quarantined also.  She is right now, for a period of two weeks, being forced to stay in her house.  So this is just an incredible situation.

Last night, I spoke to President Xi.  We talked about the experience that they had in China and all of the things that have taken place.  And we learned a lot.  They’ve had a very tough experience, and they’re doing well and he’s doing well.  President Xi is doing very well.  But we learned a lot and we have great communication together.

We’re going to be sent great data from China — things that happened that they see that — you know, they’ve had a — they’ve had an early experience, and we’re getting all of that information.  Much of it has already been sent.  It was sent yesterday and sent to our scientists to study.  So we’ll have more on that also.  We’ll be discussing that at 5:30.

I just want to thank the people behind me.  They’ve been incredible friends.  They’ve been warriors.  They — there’s nobody tougher or smarter than the people standing alongside of me.  And I think I want to start off by asking Mitch and then Kevin to speak, and then we’re going to go through a few of the folks in the room if they’d like to say something.

But, Mitch, I’d like — I’d love to say a few words because you — this man worked 24 hours a day for a long time.  This is the result.  It’s the biggest ever — ever approved in Congress: 6.2 bill- — $6.2 trillion.  So, you know, we used to get used to the billion.  It used to be million, then it was billion, now it’s trillion.  And it’s going to go a long way.  It’s going to make a lot of people very happy.

Mitch McConnell, please.

LEADER MCCONNELL:  Thank you, Mr. President.  Let me just say this is a proud moment for our country, for the President.  The Republicans and the Democrats all pulled together and passed the biggest bill in history in record time.

I also want to thank Kevin McCarthy and our leaders on the Republican side in the House who helped speed this through to passage.  The American people needed this rescue package, they needed it quickly, and we delivered.  It’s a proud moment for all of us.  Mr. President, thanks for the opportunity to be here.

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you.  I’d love to shake your hand, but Anthony would get angry at me if I did that.  (Laughter.)  So I better not do it.  I can’t — it’s so natural.  I just want to go back and shake his hand.

They’ve done such an incredible job.  Kevin, please.

LEADER MCCARTHY:  Yeah, I do want to start.  I want to thank all — the real — the real answer to America is: We’re listening to you.  You do your part, and we’re going to do ours, and that’s exactly what’s happening today.

What Leader McConnell did was amazing.  He made it bipartisan, bicameral.  Everybody was involved.  I wish we could have signed this earlier this week; maybe there wouldn’t be as many people who are out of work.  But this will put people back to work.

I also want to thank Secretary Mnuchin.  You’ve done an amazing job, and we thank you for that, and all the team that’s here.

Look, as I said in my speech, the virus is here.  We didn’t ask for it.  We didn’t invite it.  We didn’t choose it.  But we are going to defeat it together because we’re going to work together, and this is the first start of it.  The hospitals will get money — the money they need.  The small businesses will be able to hire their employees back.  That is a grant; you don’t have to borrow from that place.  The other businesses get a retention to keep your employees on.  This has something for everything.

And to the task force and the Vice President, all the work that you’re doing with this President, this will be the needed resources you need as well.  And thank you for that, and thank you for your leadership, Mr. President.

THE PRESIDENT:  Very special.

Mike Pence?  Mike?  Could you please say something?  You’ve been working very hard, in charge of our task force.  And then I’d like to ask Steve to say a few words.

THE VICE PRESIDENT:  Thank you, Mr. President.  Thanks for giving me the opportunity just to express all of our appreciation and the gratitude to the American people for the accomplishment that’s reflected in the legislation that you’ll sign in just a few moments.

You told the American people that we would do whatever it takes.  You called on the Congress to step forward to make coronavirus testing free for every American, to make paid family leave available.

The Congress, with the leaders gathered around us here, stepped forward in a bipartisan fashion and delivered.  But today, every American family, every American business, can know that help is on the way.

And I want to thank Leader McConnell for his yeoman’s work in really forging a bipartisan bill in the United States Senate.  I want to thank Leader McCarthy for his great work.  But as the President said, I also want to thank the Democrat and Republican leadership across the House and Senate.  This is an American accomplishment.  And, Mr. President, it’s exactly what you asked the Congress to deliver for the American people.

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you very much, Mike.  And Steve Mnuchin, you know how hard he’s been working.  And, Steve, please say a few words.

SECRETARY MNUCHIN:  Mr. President, thank you very much for your leadership and for the Vice President’s leadership.  You made it very clear to us, last week, we should think big, that this was a war on the virus, and that we should have the resources to protect American workers and American business.

And I’d like to thank the Senate.  It was a great honor, Mitch, to work with you and everyone on a bipartisan basis to get this done.  This is going to be a great thing for the American workers.  And, Kevin McCarthy, thank you for all the work in the House did to pass this quickly.

So, at Treasury, as I’ve said, we are committed to move forward quickly, and we’re going to get money in people’s pockets quickly.

Thank you, Mr. President.

THE PRESIDENT:  Great job, Steve.  Gene?  Please.

SECRETARY SCALIA:  This is a great day for American workers, protecting American workers, American jobs.  It’s been a hallmark of this presidency, and this bill today is another very important step in that direction.  It includes unprecedented support for American workers who’ve lost their jobs, through no fault of their own because of this virus, and gives them, as near as we could, the same wage they would have gotten, through unemployment insurance if they’d been able to keep their jobs, for up to four months.

I think even more important, it includes $350 billion in loans for small business, but it’s structured in a way to incentivize them to keep their workers on payroll so that those loans could be forgiven at the end of the period.
And it comes on top of legislation the President asked — signed last week for paid leave for workers who have to be at home because of the virus.  Paid leave reimbursed in full, dollar for dollar, to the employers.  It’s the first federal paid leave law for the private sector ever.  And that also was achieved on an unprecedented, bipartisan basis.

This is the third major bipartisan piece of legislation in three weeks — three bills, three weeks — to address this virus.

So again, I want to thank the President for his leadership, his commitment to American workers, the Vice President as well, and Leader McConnell, and also my colleague, Secretary Mnuchin who did work so hard to help you get this done.

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you, Gene, very much.

Dr. Fauci, you may want to just say for a minute what hit the world.  Something hit the world, and the world maybe will never be the quite same.  But we’re going to make it a great place anyway.  But certainly, you could maybe say a few words about it, please.

DR. FAUCI:  Well, thank you, Mr. President.  And I want to thank everyone involved in this.  This is what America is all about: a bipartisan approach, with your leadership, to do something that’s sorely needed by the American people.

Dr. Birx and I and all of our medical people here are fighting the virus directly.  But the virus has an impact on the American people, both directly by illness and death, but also indirectly, because many of the things that we have to do to suppress the virus has a negative impact because of what we’re doing.  To give them relief economically is absolutely essential.

So I feel really, really good about what’s happening today.  Thank you all very much.

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you, Tony.  Thank you very much.

Deborah, perhaps you could say a few words or so about —

DR. BIRX:  Well, thank you, Mr. President.  Dr. Fauci covered it very well.  As many of you know, I worked for him and he was my mentor 40 years ago.

I think whenever we start with one of these very serious diseases and a pandemic, the President’s first goal was ensuring the health of the American people, and that’s why we put out these very strong guidance.

It’s been a pleasure to work with the economic team here because they understand data in the same way.  Economic data and health data is very similar in how you have to interpret it in a very granular way.  And I think recognizing that the health of the American people is first, but the economic value of the nation is also critical.

And I just want to thank all of you for what you’ve done for the American people today.

THE PRESIDENT:  Great job you’re doing too.  Thank you.

Kevin, please.

REPRESENTATIVE BRADY:  So just 20 days ago, I don’t know that anyone could have imagined how hard we’ve been hit medically or economically.  But 20 days ago, I don’t think anyone could have imagined Congress pulling together so quickly and so forcefully behind what the President identified we needed for this country.  This is a proud moment for all of us.  And it’s just an example of what leadership can provide here in the White House, and then how we can respond as a Congress.

So thank you, Mr. President, for your leadership.

THE PRESIDENT:  And I’m just saying, as Kevin is saying that, 20 days ago — a couple of days longer than that, maybe — we had a smooth-running, beautiful machine.  We had the greatest economy in the history of our country.  We had the highest stock price we’ve ever seen.  It went up, I think, 151 times during the course of the presidency.  And then we got hit by the invisible enemy, and we got hit hard.  But it wasn’t just us, it was 151 countries, I think, as of the — as of this morning.

And you call Germany and speak to Angela — she’s in quarantine.  And as you know, Boris was diagnosed that he’s positive.  And all of the things that are happening, it’s hard to believe what’s gone on just in a short period of time.

And because of the talent behind me and lots of other talent in government, what we’ve done — this is a big part of it, obviously, but not the biggest part.  Everybody has pulled together.  Our nation has pulled together.  The spirit is incredible.  The people have pulled together more than anyone and better than anybody.  And they’re doing really, really well.

But just to think how life can change where you go, 20 to 22 days ago, everything is perfect, we’re looking forward.  I’m saying, “When are we going to hit 30,000?  I want 30,000.”  That means more jobs and more everything.  And then, one day, we get hit with this thing that nobody ever heard of before.  Nobody ever even heard of before.  And now we’re fighting a different battle.

But I really think, in a fairly short period of time, because of what they’ve done and what everyone has done, I really think we’re going to be stronger than ever.  And we’ll be protected from a lot of this.  A lot of the things, Anthony, that we’ve done now — that we’re doing now — are going to protect us in the future if this should happen again.

DR. FAUCI:  Absolutely.

THE PRESIDENT:  From testing to so many other —

DR. FAUCI:  Vaccines.

THE PRESIDENT:  Even stockpiles.  Right?

DR. FAUCI:  And vaccines.

THE PRESIDENT:  Yeah, the vaccines, hopefully.  And vaccines, cures, therapeutics — whatever you want to call it — it’s a lot of progress.  And I think on that score, I think we’re going to do a lot of progress on vaccines.  We’re making, perhaps, a lot of progress on cures and therapeutics.  We’ll be letting you know.

Anybody else have anything?  Greg, please.  Go ahead, fellas.

REPRESENTATIVE WALDEN:  I would just say, I’ve never seen you shy away from a challenge.  Your leadership and your policies and this great team brought America this enormous economy.  And guess what?  You get to do it again.  This bill is the next step in that, and we can build back this economy with your leadership and with the healthcare team you’ve got here too.  We’re doing the right thing for the American people, and they know that.  I can tell you that from the ground.  It’s not easy.  It’s not easy.

THE PRESIDENT:  No, it’s not.

REPRESENTATIVE WALDEN:  We don’t want to shelter in place, as Americans.  We want to be out, especially northwest.

THE PRESIDENT:  Yeah.

REPRESENTATIVE WALDEN:  But we know we have to do this for the safety of our relatives and families and our community and our country.  So thanks for your leadership —

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you very much.

REPRESENTATIVE WALDEN:  — and the great team you’ve assembled.

THE PRESIDENT:  Appreciate it very much.

REPRESENTATIVE CHABOT:  On behalf of small businesses, they’re the backbone of the American economy.  About half the people that work in America work for a small business, and they’re hurting out there right now.  I’m from Ohio.  I’m the ranking member of the House Small Business Committee.  And back there, nonessential small businesses are shut down.

Without this legislation, it’s questionable whether they would reopen.  Because of this legislation, they now have a great chance of that.  And those people that work for small businesses, who are shuttered now, will be paid.  That’s really important.  This wouldn’t have passed without your leadership, Mr. President.  Thank you.

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you very much.  And, you know, Eric worked so hard.  You all know Eric.  And he was at Steve’s side the whole way.  And where is our man?  Do I see Larry?  Yeah, Larry.  The two of them.  How about Eric and then Larry say a couple of words and (inaudible.)

MR. UELAND:  Well, thank you very much, Mr. President.  I really appreciate it, and Mr. Vice President, as well.  So you encouraged your team to be bold, be brave, and go big.  And we certainly delivered today.  (Laughter.)  $6.2 trillion is tremendous.  So we’ve made sure that we can reassure Americans that their paycheck is protected and that their earnings are protected.  We’ve made sure that we can provide significant reinforcement to the American economy as a result of your leadership.

And, finally, looking ahead to address the virus, we’ve included significant resources in order to ensure that those therapies and ultimately that vaccine can come online as quickly as possible.  So, protecting the public health and protecting the economic health of America is what you’ve directed us to do.  And together, with the team, we’ve worked hard to deliver today.

Thank you very much, Mr. President.

THE PRESIDENT:  Thank you very much.  And Steve is going to work very hard on getting the money out quickly, and hopefully it can be distributed very quickly, especially when they have some old computer equipment that they have to use.  But you’re going to work on that very hard.

SECRETARY MNUCHIN:  We are indeed.

THE PRESIDENT:  Larry, please.  Larry Kudlow.

MR. KUDLOW:  Oh, thanks, sir.  Just hats off to Mitch McConnell who did an amazing job, and House leadership as well.  And I agree with the bipartisanship.  I want to give special thanks to my friend Steven Mnuchin, who I think did an extraordinary job.  We were up there helping him out in one spot or another.  But he’s indefatigable and got it done.

And I’ll just say this, Mr. President: A few months ago, this economy was roaring and we’ve hit this — literally, this bug, this virus.  And we will deal with it.  And I think the assistance bill here, which does have growth incentives, will help lead us back to a very strong economic rebound before this year is over.

Thank you, sir.

THE PRESIDENT:  I think that too.  I think we’re going to have a tremendous rebound at the end of the year — toward the end of the year.  I think we’re going to have a rebound like we have never seen before.  Even now it wants to rebound.  You can see it, feel it.  It wants to rebound so badly.

And, you know, we’ve had those really big — I guess, the biggest-ever stock market surge two days ago.  And yesterday, it was great.  Three biggest days in the history of the stock market.  It wants to rebound so badly, but we have to get rid of the bug, we have to get rid of the virus.

Now, I’m going to sign this, and it’s a great honor — $6.2 trillion.  I’ve never signed anything with a “T” on it.  (Laughter.)  I don’t know if I can handle this one, Mitch.  (Laughter.)  We can’t chicken out at this point, can we?.  (Laughter.)  I don’t think so, huh?

All right.  Thank you all.

(The CARES Act is signed.)

THE PRESIDENT:  Good.  I wanted them to be a nice signature. (Applause.)  Come on, fellas.  Come on over here.  Elaine.  What a job she’s doing with transportation.  How’s transportation?  Okay?

SECRETARY CHAO:  Fine.  You always talk about the supply chain.

THE PRESIDENT:  I do.

SECRETARY CHAO:  It’s really important.

THE PRESIDENT:  I do.

SECRETARY CHAO:  This bill is going to help the supply chain and the workers.

THE PRESIDENT:  Anthony?  Thank you.  Thanks, Tony, very much.  Bob Lighthizer, thank you very much.  Bob was a little less involved in this.  He’s too busy making trade deals.

Okay?  You have one?  You definitely have to have one.  Go ahead.  You’re all set.

Thank you, everybody.  So we’re going to have a 5:30 news conference in the same location.  Seems to be doing quite well.  And we appreciate everything.  And we really appreciate the fairness, at least from most of the press.  We really do.  Thank you very much, everybody.  Thank you.  Thank you very much.

Q    Mr. President, there was that rare moment of agreement today between you and Senator Kerry over —

THE PRESIDENT:  That’s right.

Q    — this issue with Massie.  Can you expand a bit on that?

THE PRESIDENT:  Well, he made a little joke about a man named Congressman Massie.  I thought he was totally out of line — Congressman Massie.  Because of that, I guess a lot of people had to come back, and they had to go into a place, which, frankly, we’re not supposed to be at, you know, in light of — of what we’re doing with Deborah and Tony and all of the professionals.

So people had to come back, and just no reason for it.  So John Kerry made a little joke out of it, and I agreed with his joke.  And I said, I never knew he had that kind of a personality.  But we actually put it up, and he was right.

Okay, we’ll see you in a couple of minutes, folks.  Thank you very much.

END

4:33 P.M. EDT



House Speaker Nancy Pelosi
March 27, 2020

Pelosi Floor Speech in Support of H.R. 748, the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act

Washington, D.C. – Speaker Nancy Pelosi delivered remarks on the Floor of the House of Representatives in support of H.R. 748, the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act.  Below are the Speaker’s remarks:

Speaker Pelosi.  Thank you very much, Mr. Speaker.

I thank the distinguished Democratic Leader Mr. Hoyer for yielding and for the manner in which he has enabled so many of our Members to participate in this debate today.  Thank you, Mr. Hoyer, for your leadership on the legislation and also for leading us today.  And I thank Mr. Brady for his leadership as well, for facilitating this conversation.  And I thank you, Mr. Speaker, for keeping us reasonably on time, as much as possible for Congressional Members.  Thank you for the strength of your authority as Speaker Pro Tempore today.  I thank all Members on both sides of the aisle for the seriousness with which we have all taken this important challenge.

Mr. Speaker, last week, His Holiness Pope Francis said, in his world prayer, he said, ‘Enlighten those responsible for the common good, so that they might know how to care for those entrusted to their responsibility.’  That is His Holiness' quote.  And that is the responsibility that we all have.

Today, as we have all acknowledged, our nation faces an economic and health emergency of historic proportions due to the coronavirus pandemic, the worst pandemic in over 100 years.  As I proceed with my remarks, I want to say to our colleagues, who are watching the proceedings from their chambers in the House, to come forward and come to the Gallery and listen from here, so that when the time comes we will be prepared to proceed.  The distinguished Leader on the Republican side, Mr. McCarthy, and Mr. Hoyer have sent a communication to all of you to that effect.  But it is very important that you come now.  The sooner you come, the shorter my remarks will be.

[Laughter]

And I want to thank the distinguished Leader on the Republican side for his leadership throughout all of this to achieve a bipartisan legislation and to do so as expeditiously as possible in the House, in the House, so that the message will be clear to the American people that whatever concerns we may have and whatever we want to do next, right now we're going to pass this legislation.  And that is because so many American families have been touched by this crisis.

More than 82,000 Americans so far have fallen sick – a number certain to surge as testing goes forward – which is already the most in the world.  We've gone past China and Italy.  More than 1,200 Americans have tragically died.  It gives you chills just to think of it.  Millions of workers are losing their paychecks, including more than, as has been mentioned on both sides of the aisle, 3.2 million Americans who filed for unemployment last week alone.  A staggering, record-shattering figure.  Countless health care workers, first responders and others fighting on the front lines in this crisis are at great personal risk.

The American people deserve a government-wide, visionary, evidence-based response to address these threats to their lives and their livelihoods, and they need it now.  Again, I acknowledge the bipartisanship in which we – on which we bring this legislation to the Floor.

Last night – late Wednesday night, as the Leader acknowledged, the Senate unanimously passed legislation which transformed, in our view – since you acknowledged, Leader McConnell, I will acknowledge our distinguished chairmen on our side, which – they transformed a Republican, corporate-focused bill into a Democratic, workers-first focus.  And we salute our chairs, working in a bipartisan way and in a bicameral way, across the aisle, across the Capitol, we are able to dramatically expand Unemployment Insurance and defeated attempts on the Senate side to claw back the $600 per week added benefits that would provide essential relief to the record number of Americans losing their jobs.

And I salute Chairmen Richie Neal and Bobby Scott for the work that they did on this.  I know this is the work of the Ways and Means Committee.  And successfully achieve full direct payment for workers, this is so important, ensuring that working class American families will be eligible to receive as much as $3,400 dollars for a family of four.  I thank, again, Mr.  Neal and Madam Chair of the Financial Services Committee, Maxine Waters, who – both of them had bigger proposals.  But, nonetheless, advocating for all this.

By the way, I would suggest, instead of saying it's going to take a few weeks for the checks to get there, that the Administration electronically transfer those direct payments immediately.

We ensured in the bill that any taxpayer dollars given to industry goes first and foremost to workers.  Workers' paychecks and benefits, not used to pay CEO bonuses, stocks, fund buybacks or dividends and the rest.  And I thank – and we have secured robust special oversight that will hold the Administration accountable for this.  And I thank the distinguished Chair of the – where did he go?  Energy and – the Infrastructure and Transportation Committee, Mr. DeFazio, for his leadership in that regard.  I will not try to find all of you because you may be in the Gallery as we are encouraging Members to come.  Here we go.

We're also proud – again, I want to salute the Congresswoman Waters for the work, for the holding – having the oversight provisions in the bill for the account that is going to be spending money out.

We're also proud to have secured truly historic investment of hundreds of billions of dollars in hospitals, health systems, state and local governments, ensuring that they have the tools they need to combat the virus.  I salute Chairman Pallone, Congress – Chairwoman Lowey of the Appropriations Committee and Chairwoman DeLauro for making so much of all of that possible.  And when we talk about state and local government, I want to express pride in our own Governor, Gavin Newsom.  He was on the front line of attacking this, as well as my own Mayor Breed who has disciplined us to shelter in place.

For small businesses, thank you, Congresswoman – Madam Chair Velazquez.  And working in a bipartisan way, we want fast relief for those in need, including by securing $10 billion for SBA emergency grants of up to $10,000, and making payroll costs, rent, mortgage interest and utility costs eligible for SBA loan forgiveness.  And for the first time, we have grants from the SBA and, thanks to Secretary Mnuchin – he is facilitating this by not just all of the loans going through the SBA, but going through banks with the SBA, which makes this all go much faster.

For our students, we've passed payments for – paused payments for federal student loan borrowers, paused the payments, and suspended wage garnishment and negative credit reporting during this time for that and for so many other things relating to our students.  I thank Bobby Scott, our Chairman of Education and [Labor].

And for our veterans, you heard earlier all of these chairmen make these presentations.  For our veterans we secured nearly $20 billion dollars in funding to improve VA’s readiness with equipment, tests and additional care, as, again 571 veterans and 185 employees have now tested positive.  I thank Chairman Takano and others on the Committee for their leadership.

For our homeowners, renters and homeless creditors, again, I thank – and consumers, I thank Chairwoman Waters for her leadership there.

Since the beginning of this crisis, we have fought to ensure that our nation's response puts families first.  As we go through this.  So the first two bills – that we worked in a bipartisan way on – were about addressing the emergency.  The first bill was about testing, testing, testing, to ensure that everyone in the country would have access to free testing, among other things.  It had in there issues that relate to research for vaccines, research for a cure, but many other things, addressing the emergency.  In the second bill, which also focused on the emergency, we have masks, masks, masks and many other provisions focused on the emergency.

But taking us to this bill today, which is about mitigation.  The distinguished Mr. DeFazio would say, ‘first we had emergency, then we had mitigation.’  Doesn't mean we're finished with emergency.  But it's moving on to mitigating some of the economic and health damage caused by it this pandemic.

Next, we'll move to recovery and hopefully that will be soon.  Always, though, addressing the emergency and the mitigation needed.

How are we coming, Mr. Leaders?  How are we coming with our Gallery?

Speaker Pro Tempore.  The House is not in order.

Speaker Pelosi.  As we have all said universally, and we say it almost all the time that we come to the Floor, no bill is perfect.  No bill is perfect.  But we want to make sure that at least it comes part of the way to being sufficient.  I do think that we should, when we're considering a bill, appreciate for what is in the bill rather than judge it for what is not in the bill.  But we do know that we must do more.

There's been a constant communication among all of our Members – I'm sure on both sides of the aisle –  when you're at home or here, with doctors, health care providers, laborers, small businesses, nonprofits, faith groups and scientists on the daily needs and developments in your communities.  The on-the-ground reports and clear-eyed thinking we have are essential to crafting our approach to all of this.  So, again, listening to Members on both sides of the aisle and the comments here today, as well as the input you have been giving in the legislative process we know that this cannot be our final bill.

Yet, this bill, again, is – I think Bobby Scott called it a down payment.  We must advance a fourth bill to address the continued needs.  For our fight against the coronavirus, our state and local governments will need vastly more support for preventing, preparing for and responding to the crisis.  Our hospitals and health systems still need vast infusions of funding so they can treat those in need.  We must do more for our health care workers – and this has been a current theme on both sides of the aisle, our gratitude for our health care workers.  They are our heroes.  We're thankful and grateful to them.  We pray for them.  But we need to do more for them than just to say those words.

Our front line health care workers, and whether they're emergency need, our firefighters, our law enforcement, face a dire lack of medical and personal protective equipment – PPE – personal protective equipment.  That's the reference.  When you see PPE, that's what it is.  We must ensure that the President uses the Defense Production Act to its full extent to provide the tools that we need to combat this crisis.

All workers are risking their lives on the front lines of this fight and need stronger OSHA protections to keep them safe.  Thank you, Mr. Scott.

This week, for example, for example – and you probably all have examples – this week we learned of the tragic death of Kious Kelly, a nurse manager in New York who died in the line of duty from coronavirus.  He and his fellow nurses risked their lives without proper protective equipment, because the hospital supply simply did not have enough.  Nurses were given a single plastic protective gown to use for an entire shift when protocol called for a change of gowns between interactions with patients.  Other nurses were forced to resort to tying bandanas over their faces in place of proper equipment.  And still others even began tying plastic garbage bags around disposable scrubs they were given in place of proper scrubs for extra protection.  As Mr. Kelly's sister said, ‘His death could have been prevented.  I'm angry.  He was healthy.’

And now our nurses, doctors, health care workers and first responders need action.  We have to make sure they know that help is not only on the way, but it is a priority for all of us.  These people risk their lives trying to save other people's lives.  Then they take home what they interacted within an infected environment – take home.  This is just asking far too much.

Our families our workers, our retirees still need more money in their pockets to protect their income security, with increased SNAP.  One thing we couldn't get in the bill was the increased – the fifteen percent increase in food stamps for our children, for our seniors, for those who qualify.

Bigger direct payments – I hope that we'll be in agreement.  I know that Richie and Maxine had the idea of ongoing direct payments, so bigger direct payments.  Pension protections – we had a protection in the legislation.  It was supported by everyone.  The President of the United States supported it, but Senator McConnell said he would save it for the next bill.  So, that's why I'm mentioning it, for the next bill.

And then we need more expanded family and medical leave.  Let me give you an example.  Come on, my colleagues, to the Gallery.  Let me give you an example.  If your parent is sick, but had an ongoing caregiver in the home or went to a senior health center on a daily basis, and because of the virus that caregiver couldn't come or that health center was closed, you would be able to give – you would be able to take family and medical leave.

However, as in the case of many Members here, if your mom or your dad are healthy, and they contract the coronavirus, you would not be able to take family and medical leave.  But we would like that to say, ‘It’s for those who cannot care for themselves – who cannot care for themselves.’  It just doesn't make any sense in my view.  So in any case, we need that and without exception.

And all Americans need free coronavirus treatments so they don't have to fear the high cost of a hospital stay.  When we said the tests were free, it didn't mean the test is free but the visit to the doctor is not.

So, in the days and weeks to come, Democrats will continue to advance legislation to meet the urgent needs of all affected by the coronavirus.  I keep saying the coronavirus because in this – people say, ‘How come we didn't do this or that?’  Because this is specific to the coronavirus challenge that we have.

I just want to say a word about our children as I close.  So many of our children – I want them if they are paying attention – distinguished Congresswoman Brooks mentioned the children.  We are so sad for them that they cannot be fully engaged in school as they were.  Some have access to remote learning and the rest.  And this has had a deep impact on American life as it affects our children as well.

When I see that some graduations have been canceled – and hopefully not so many more if we can get through this – and they – I’ve been, as a mother of five, grandmother of nine personally, but officially in my leadership role, I have seen hundreds of thousands of graduates.  And what's exciting about it personally and officially is to see the excitement of the families when their child graduates.  But when that family happens to have someone on the stage who is the first in the family to graduate, the pride, the joy, the patriotism, all of it is so exuberant and many of them will be deprived of that experience of seeing that child walk across the stage.

Let's try to get this.  We have the best minds working 24/7, all hands on deck to find a cure.  Let's make sure that we give them the resources they need to do so.  But at the same time, that we obey the science that says shelter in place or whatever it happens to be.

As we go forward, let us pray.  Let us remember what His Holiness told us, what he told us was that we have a responsibility for the common good.  So, let us pray for all the ones who have lost family members and others struggling with the illness now.  Let's pray for our heroic health care workers and first responders who are risking their lives to care for the sick every day; the men and women in our factories making more medical supplies and personal protective equipment; the farmers, producers, grocery workers keeping food on the shelves; our truck drivers; postal workers; everybody who is contributing to the effort; and the scientists, as I say, all hands on deck, 24/7 for a solution.

Congress must show the same courage, same resilience, same strength and with a great unity and urgency to put families and workers first.  Let me, again, thank everyone who had anything to do with this, and that means almost everybody in this room.  Let me thank the Senate Democrats and Leader Schumer for his work, as you acknowledge Leader McConnell.

Let us, again, return to the words of His Holiness, Pope Francis.  ‘May we enlighten those responsible for the common good so that they may know how to care for their – those entrusted to their responsibility.’

With that I hope we have the biggest possible vote for the American people to show them that Congress' heart and the country's heart is full of love for the American people.

And with that, Mr. Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time.


the campaigns respond...
Donald J. Trump for President, Inc.
March 26, 2020

President Trump Is Providing Immediate Economic Relief for Americans Impacted by the Coronavirus

President Trump has mobilized the entire federal government to provide economic relief for Americans impacted by the crisis.

As the latest economic data makes clear, millions of American workers have been impacted by the coronavirus. That’s why President Trump has taken – and continues to take – concrete actions to provide immediate economic relief.

A $2.2 trillion economic relief package passed the Senate and currently awaits a vote in the House. “I encourage the House to pass this vital legislation and send the bill to my desk for signature without delay,” President Trump said yesterday. “I will sign it immediately.” The legislation provides:

  • $300 billion in direct cash payments available for every American citizen earning less than $99,000 per year.
  • $250 billion in expanded unemployment benefits. The average worker who has lost his or her job will receive 100% of their salary for up to four full months. Unlike normal unemployment benefits, independent contractors and self-employed workers will be eligible.
  • $350 billion in job retention loans for small businesses, with loan forgiveness available for businesses that continue paying their workers.
  • $500 billion in support for the hardest hit industries, with a ban on corporate stock buybacks.
In addition, the Trump administration has taken a series of actions to provide economic relief to Americans impacted by the coronavirus:

  • President Trump signed legislation that provides paid sick and family leave for workers experiencing coronavirus-related employment interruptions.
  • The Trump Administration directed federal student loan lenders to allow borrowers to waive interest and payments without penalty for 60 days.
  • The Trump Administration directed the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to provide immediate relief to renters and homeowners by suspending all foreclosures and evictions.
  • President Trump directed the Small Business Administration to issue low-interest loans to small businesses affected by the coronavirus.
  • President Trump signed legislation providing funding and flexibility for emergency nutritional aid for senior citizens, women, children, and low-income families.
  • The Department of Labor announced up to $100 million in dislocated worker grants in response to the coronavirus national health emergency.
Learn more about the Trump Administration's timeline of action against the coronavirus here.

Biden for President
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
March 26, 2020

Joe Biden Announces Emergency Action Plan to Save the Economy

 Tonight, Joe Biden is releasing an emergency action plan to save the economy, laying out three key steps he would take as president to tackle the ongoing pandemic and safeguard our country’s economic prosperity. In a new video speaking directly to Americans, Vice President Biden outlined his emergency action plan and highlighted the immediate, impactful steps that can be taken to defeat the virus and protect the livelihood of working families.

FACT SHEET: The Biden Emergency Action Plan to Save the Economy

Congress is close to passing a massive relief bill. When it passes, it’s all about execution — and filling in the gaps.
 
If Joe Biden were President right now, here are the three things he would do now to save our economy and help our families weather the storm.  And to get them done, he would appoint a task force reporting twice-daily to him on progress.
 
FIRST, use all available authorities, including the Defense Production Act to turn the tide on this epidemic. Joe Biden knows that no economic strategy will work if we don’t stop the virus. In recent days, there’s been talk that we have to choose between public health and our economy. That’s not just a false choice. It’s a dangerous one.
 
It would be catastrophic to reopen everything without a plan, and then have a spike in cases and shut it all back down. That would just mean more loss of life and economic pain.
 
To reopen, public health experts say we need real testing capacity, the ability to trace contacts if someone tests positive, and the ability to surge equipment and supplies to any new hotspots. We should listen to them. It’s the quickest, surest way to getting our economy back on track. And we also need to address the shortage of items like ventilators and personal protective equipment for health care workers, and make sure our workforce on the frontlines everyday has the protections to provide the essential services we will continue to need.  Joe Biden would use the full powers of the presidency and this government to make that happen. 
 
Joe Biden would end this epidemic and get our economy back on track through bold action -- not by picking an arbitrary date on the calendar and asserting it's over.
 
SECOND, launch a task force reporting directly to me to make sure every dollar going out the door gets to the people who need it — fast.
 
Joe Biden led the implementation of the Recovery Act in the last crisis.  He knows it’s all about priorities. Here would be his:
  • Keep as many people on the payroll as possible and make Americans whole for lost hours and wages. Joe Biden would expedite aid to businesses who commit to helping workers stay employed through the crisis, so they can get back to work when conditions allow.  He would maximize work-sharing, a form of “employment insurance” we championed in the Obama-Biden administration to keep more workers on the job. And for those who do get laid off and who’s industries are out of work, the congressional bill boosts unemployment benefits — Biden would cut through the red tape to deliver them without delay, and extend them as long as public health and economic conditions call for it.
  • Act decisively to keep small businesses in business. Included in the legislation before Congress is $377 billion for small businesses. This money will guarantee immediate loans that banks provide to small businesses to make payroll, pay rent and other costs, and keep their doors open. But there is a real risk it won’t get out fast enough to make a difference.  So Joe Biden would take unprecedented measures to get it done  Where the government is guaranteeing loans, banks have no commercial excuse for not making them. So he would call in bank CEOs and tell them that in this time of crisis, it is a matter of the utmost national interest to get these loans out the door quickly and efficiently. And if they don’t, he would seek authority similar to the Defense Production Act to make sure their lending platforms are giving priority to small business. He would also make clear that $377 billion is not a cap -- we will spend whatever it takes. 
  • Enforce real conditions and oversight on big corporations.  Joe Biden would tell large companies seeking taxpayer assistance that they need to make hard commitments that the assistance will go toward their workers, not toward enriching their CEOs or shareholders. He would hold the strictest line on bans on buybacks and raises for executives. He would impose the highest scrutiny on payroll plans. And he would impose strict oversight and enforcement of these conditions by appointing strong regulators focused on corporate accountability and worker protections in the event of bankruptcy. Joe Biden will not let companies off the hook, the way the White House and Senate originally proposed.
THIRD, bring the leaders of Congress together to build the next deal. This was a good start. But more must be done. Congress approved direct cash relief -- $1,200 per person to help working families through this crisis.  But it’s a one-off.  And Congress didn't include direct student loan forgiveness, or Social Security boosts for seniors, or cost-free treatment for COVID-19, full paid sick leave for our workers, or sufficient fiscal relief to states.  Joe Biden would:
  • Provide for additional checks to families should conditions require.
  • Forgive a minimum of $10,000 per person of federal student loans, as proposed by Senator Warren and colleagues. Young people and other student debt holders bore the brunt of the last crisis. It shouldn't happen again.
  • Increase monthly Social Security checks by $200/month, as proposed by Senator Wyden and colleagues. Seniors and people with disabilities are uniquely at risk right now.
  • Provide emergency paid sick leave to everyone who needs it, with no one left out. This should include workers in all industries and all sectors, regardless of company size, and including gig workers, domestic workers, contractors, and the self-employed.
  • Ensure that no one has to pay a dollar out of pocket for COVID-19 testing, treatment, or an eventual vaccine.
  • Provide all necessary fiscal relief to states so their workers and communities get the help they need, especially those on the front lines like New York.
The bottom line is that Congress will have to keep acting. This is not the last bill.  There will be more. And Joe Biden would do whatever it takes, spend whatever it takes, move heaven and earth to help all the people harmed by this crisis.

###


Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
03.25.00

McConnell on Bipartisan Coronavirus Relief: “The Senate Stepped Up”

‘The Senate will act to help the people of this country weather this storm… When our nation comes through this and takes flight again on the other side, it will be because American heroes won this fight. All the Senate can do is give them the resources to do it. So that’s exactly what we are going to do today.’

WASHINGTON, D.C.  U.S. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) delivered the following remarks today on the Senate floor regarding the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act:

“It has only been 65 days since the first American tested positive for the new coronavirus on our soil.

“In barely two months, this pandemic has upended our nation.

“As of this morning, more than 175 million Americans have been advised to remain in their homes. More than half of our people are effectively sheltering in place.

“Hospitals in major cities are pushing capacity. Doctors and nurses are exhausting crucial supplies.
“And if it were not enough for Americans to fight to stay healthy, they are also fighting to keep their paychecks, to keep supporting their families.

“Combating this disease has forced our country to put huge parts of national life on pause and triggered layoffs at a breathtaking pace.

“This strange new reality has forced our nation onto something like a wartime footing.

“A fight has arrived on our shores. We did not seek it. We did not want it. But now, we are going to win it.

“Ten days ago, I laid out four urgent priorities for new Senate legislation to help our nation through this crisis.

“We had to get direct financial assistance to the American people…

“Get historic aid to small businesses to keep paychecks flowing…

“Stabilize key industries to prevent mass layoffs…

“And, of course, flood more resources into the front-line healthcare battle itself.

“One week ago, Senate Republicans laid down an initial proposal that tackled each of these emergency missions.

“Our members put forward bold plans to send cash to households. Stand up historic emergency loans for Main Street. Stabilize key sectors. And put the full might of Congress behind our doctors, nurses, hospitals, healthcare providers, and the race for treatments and vaccines.

“I couldn’t be prouder of our colleagues.

“Our nation needed us to go big, and go fast, and they did.

“The creative policies our chairmen crafted in just a couple days’ time remain the central building blocks of the proposal we will pass today.

“But Republicans knew the nation had no time for conventional political gamesmanship. So the instant we released our first draft, I created a series of bipartisan working groups.

“I asked Republicans and Democrats to work together around the clock to make the bill even better.

“By Sunday, we had an updated proposal that was even stronger and contained even more ideas literally from both sides.

“Republicans and Democrats had worked together to dramatically strengthen and rework unemployment insurance during this crisis.

“We had worked together to make sure lower-income families could receive the full cash assistance. And on and on.

“I will leave it to others to compare the bipartisan Sunday bill to the final version we will pass today and determine whether the last few changes really required or merited these three days of delay, in the face of this worsening crisis.

“But that Washington drama does not matter anymore. The Senate is going to stand together, act together, and pass this historic relief package.

“Struggling Americans are going to go to their mailboxes and find four-figure checks to help with their bills...  because the Senate stepped up.

“Many American families who have poured everything into a restaurant, or a shop, or a small manufacturer are going to keep making payroll and keep their businesses alive... because the Senate stepped up.

“Hundreds of thousands of workers in key sectors who might well have been laid off through no fault of their own will instead get to keep their job and continue their career…  because the Senate stepped up.

“And for the healthcare heroes who leave their own sleeping children and drive to the hospital for the all-night shift…

“Who spend hour after hour healing the sick, comforting strangers, and literally battling this disease...

“There will be more masks in their supply closets, more funding for their hospitals, and soon, more new treatments to administer to their patients...

“Because the Senate stepped up.

“So today, the Senate will act to help the people of this country weather this storm.

“Nobody thinks legislation can end this. We cannot outlaw this virus.

“And no economic policy could fully end the hardship so long as the public health requires that we put so much of our nation’s commerce on ice.

“This is not even a stimulus package. It is emergency relief.

“No, this fight is not going to be won or lost in Washington D.C. It is the American people who will beat this virus.

“Americans will keep making sacrifices to slow down the spread. Americans will keep pitching in and looking after each other. Americans will keep finding creative ways to stand united — even if they have to stand six feet apart.

“We’ll win this fight because of people like Amy Jean Tyler, a stay-at-home mom in Oldham County, Kentucky, who is leading a drive to sew cotton masks for a local children’s hospital.

“We’ll win this fight because of people like Pastor Grant Hasty in Stearns, Kentucky who’s gathered volunteers to distribute more than 550 homecooked meals.

“We’ll win this fight because of people like Peg Hays, who runs a distillery in Christian County, Kentucky and is temporarily converting her bourbon-making facilities to churn out hand sanitizer.

“We’ll win this fight because national companies are switching production lines to make medical supplies.

“Because our largest high-tech companies are partnering with the government to throw supercomputing power into the race for vaccines.

“We’ll win this fight because of families, neighbors, and church communities that cannot even worship together in person.

“Because of small businesses. Big businesses. Public-health PhDs and local entrepreneurs.

“It has been 18 years since every American was united in amazement and prayer as firefighters and first responders rushed into burning buildings on September 11th, 2001.

“In the coming days and weeks, our nation is going to meet new heroes.

“Many may be police, firefighters, and EMTs once again.

“Many others will be truck drivers, grocery-store clerks, and pharmacists who literally keep our supply chains running.

“Utility workers and delivery drivers who leave their homes so everyone else can remain in theirs.

“Teachers who somehow manage to keep educating their students over the Internet while looking after their own kids at the same time.

“And most of all, we’re going to meet a whole lot of American heroes who wear scrubs, and masks, and gloves.

“Heroes who rush toward the sick, and wash their hands until they bleed, and work around the clock to heal our friends and our families.

“When our nation comes through this and takes flight again on the other side, it will be because American heroes won this fight.

“All the Senate can do is give them the resources to do it.

“So that’s exactly what we are going to do today.”
Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer
March 25, 2020

Schumer Floor Remarks In Advance Of Passage Of Historic Bipartisan Coronavirus Response Legislation That Puts Workers And The Health Of Americans First

Washington, D.C. – U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer today spoke on the Senate floor in advance of the passage of the historic bipartisan coronavirus response legislation that puts workers and the health of Americans first. Below are Senator Schumer’s remarks, which can also be viewed here:

The legislation now before us now is historic because it is meant to match a historic crisis. Our health care system is not prepared to care for the sick. Our workers are without work. Our businesses cannot do business. Our factories lie idle. The gears of the American economy have ground to a halt.

Our country has faced immense challenges before, but rarely so many of them at the same time.

Over the past few days, the Senate has stepped into the breach. We packed weeks or perhaps months of the legislative process into five days. Representatives from both sides of the aisle and both ends of Pennsylvania Avenue have forged a bipartisan agreement in highly partisan times, with very little time to spare.

It’s been a long, hard road, with a remarkable number of twists and turns, but for the sake of millions of Americans, it will be worth it.

It will be worth it to get help to millions of small businesses and save tens of millions of jobs.

It will be worth it to see that Americans who have lost their jobs through no fault of their own will be able to pay their rent and mortgages and put food on the table because we passed the greatest expansion of insurance to the unemployed in decades.

It will be worth it to send gloves and masks to our nurses and doctors.

It will be worth it to send ventilators and beds to our hospitals, and begin rebuilding public health infrastructure in America—a Marshall Plan in this new century for our medical system.

It was worth it to help industries step back from the brink of collapse in order to save the jobs of hundreds of thousands of Americans in those industries employ.

It will be worth it to put workers first.

It was a long, hard road. Neither side can be completely happy with the final product. But it will be worth it.

And I’m damn proud of the work we did over the past few days. Because we put in the work, because we tested the limits of exhaustion, because we didn’t immediately accept a bill drafted by only one party, the legislation before us tonight is better.

Better for our health care system and the 65,000 Americans now afflicted with COVID-19. Better for our workers. Better for our small businesses. Better for Indian Tribes. Better for our economy. And better for the American people. And so I must thank all my colleagues on both sides, especially the Chairs and Ranking Members and their staffs.

These past few days have been filled with drama. The past few hours were no exception. I know a few of my Republican friends still harbor reservations about voting for this legislation. But when there is a crisis of this magnitude, the private sector cannot solve it. Individuals, even with bravery and valor, are not powerful enough to beat it back. Government is the only force large enough to staunch the bleeding and begin healing.

This is a time when the American people need their government. This is what we were elected for. The oath we swear to the Constitution means we must protect the general welfare of the people.
So let us marshal this government into action.

There are millions of Americans watching us right now, at home on their televisions, separated from friends and family, fearful for their children and their livelihoods, unsure of when the time will come when all of our lives may return to normal.

Let us tell them, tonight, that help is on the way. That they are not truly alone. That this country, that this Senate, that this government, is here for them in a time of dire need.

This is a strange and evil disease. There is much we still don’t know about it and it is keeping us apart. When we pass this bill, instead of hugging each other, we’ll wave from a distance.

None of us can know when this plague will pass. The only thing we know for sure is that we must summon the same spirit that saw previous generations of Americans through our nation’s darkest hours. Fellowship. Sacrifice. Fortitude. Resilience.

That is what it means to be an American. With that spirit, this nation faced down war and depression and fear itself. I have no doubt that, once again, America will ultimately prevail.

###


...a tangent
U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT)
March 25, 2020

Reacting to Republican Threats to Hold Coronavirus Package Hostage, Sanders Prepared to Place Hold Over Corporate Welfare

WASHINGTION, March 25 — Unless Senators Graham (R-S.C.), Sasse (R-Neb.) and Tim Scott (R-S.C.) drop their anti-worker objections to fast-tracking the emergency coronavirus legislation, Senator Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) said today that he is prepared to put a hold on this legislation to impose strong conditions on the $500 billion corporate welfare fund:

“In my view, it would be an outrage to prevent working-class Americans to receive the emergency unemployment assistance included in this legislation. Unless these Republican Senators drop their objections, I am prepared to put a hold on this bill until stronger conditions are imposed on the $500 billion corporate welfare fund to make sure that any corporation receiving financial assistance under this legislation does not lay off workers, cut wages or benefits, ship jobs overseas, or pay workers poverty wages.”
___________________________

Americans for Limited Government
For Immediate Release                   Contact: Rick Manning
March 25, 2020                           

Senate must stop and fix drafting error that makes it more profitable to be unemployed than to keep your job

March 25, 2020, Fairfax, Va.—Americans for Limited Government President Rick Manning today issued the following statement urging the Senate to stop and fix a drafting error in the coronavirus relief bill that incentivizes unemployment over keeping your job by making it more profitable for workers to be laid off under the bill:

“The Senate must stop and fix the drafting error which inadvertently makes it more profitable for some to be on unemployment than to work.  It would be irresponsible to rely upon the Labor Department to issue a paper thin guidance or temporary regulation to try to fix the bill, when anything they do could be swept away in less than a year.  The law itself must be fixed, because regulations flow from laws, and the courts assume that the lawmakers meant what they passed into law.

“Senators Tim Scott, Ben Sasse, Rick Scott and Lindsey Graham have earned our sincere thanks for spotting the error and having the courage to slow down the process and demand that it be corrected.  Now the Senate needs to fix it, pass it, and send it to the House of Representatives.”

To view online: https://getliberty.org/2020/03/senate-must-stop-and-fix-drafting-error-that-makes-it-more-profitable-to-be-unemployed-than-to-keep-your-job/


Libertarian Party
March 25, 2020

Libertarian Party Press Release on Bailouts

In this time of fear, chaos and uncertainty, a choice must be made in the heart of every individual — to abandon one’s principles to fear, or to hold firm to them. The Libertarian Party seeks always to lead by example, and we choose to hold firm to ours.

One of the core principles of libertarianism is that governments should not pick winners and losers. Instead, the free market should make that determination. All efforts by the government to redistribute wealth inevitably result in favoritism towards the politically well-connected.

Right now, the government is also in the process of making a choice — the choice to take $2 trillion of taxes and redistribute it, citing economic security. It would be one thing if the government was simply refunding taxpayers their hard-earned money, which many believe to be the case. Unfortunately, basic math does not support this belief.

“The population of the United States is approximately 330 million. When divided among the population, $2 trillion equates to more than $6,000 per person,” said Libertarian Party Chair Nicholas Sarwark. “The government could be returning $6,000 to every person, but instead, it is planning to give $1,200 to each adult under a certain income threshold.”

Why?

“Because of bailouts,” Sarwark continued. “In exchange for the chance at a $1,200 check, every man woman and child in America will add another $6,000 to their existing $71,500 portion of the national debt to subsidize airlines, cruise lines and bureaucratic bottom lines.”

Though the final version of the bill has not been decided, early drafts indicate the balance of the $2 trillion will go to corporate bailouts and government programs. While the people are suffocating under a deluge of layoffs, cutbacks and shortages, the government is doing what government does best — spending money like it is in endless supply.

There is a distinct reality that the government has no idea what businesses and industries will survive an economic cataclysm. Government bailouts to corporations could be propping up businesses that legitimately should fail based on market activity.

Returning money directly to taxpayers is the only sure way to inject dollars into the economy where they will not be wasted.
Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer
March 25, 2020

Schumer Floor Remarks Announcing Bipartisan Agreement On Coronavirus Response Legislation That Puts Workers And Public Health First

Washington, D.C. – U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer today spoke on the Senate floor, announcing a bipartisan agreement for coronavirus response legislation that puts workers and the public health of Americans first. Below are Senator Schumer’s remarks, which can also be viewed here:

After five days of arduous negotiations, after sleep-deprived nights and marathon negotiating sessions, we have a bipartisan agreement on the largest rescue package in American history.

This is not a moment of celebration but one of necessity. We have the anguish of the American people—wondering about the future of their health, the health of their loved ones and the economy—necessitates us to do all we can to help them and help our country.

From the very beginning, Democrats have had two primary goals: a Marshall Plan for public health workers and hospitals on the front lines, and putting workers first.

The agreement now, after these five days, reflects those Democratic priorities, and we are proud that they are now part of this legislation.

Like all compromises, this bill is far from perfect, but we believe the legislation has been improved significantly to warrant its quick consideration and passage, and because many Democrats and Republicans were willing to do the serious and hard work, the bill is much better off than where it started. Democrats have succeeded in making the bill substantially better on many counts.

Here are four major pillars of the bill.

First, a Marshall Plan for our hospitals and medical needs. There is much more money for our hospitals, for our nurses and physicians, for our nursing homes, for our community health centers to do the job they need to do—over $130 billion.

Second, workers first. So many people are being put out of work through no fault of their own. They don't know what their future is gonna be like. How are they going to pay the bills? Well, we come to their rescue, and the most significant part of that is something we are proud to have devised—we call it unemployment compensation on steroids. Every American worker who is laid off will have their salary remunerated by the federal government so they can pay their bills. And because so many of them will be furloughed rather than fired, if they have benefits, they can continue, and—extremely important—they can stay with the company or small business. And that means that company or small business can reassemble once this awful plague is over and our economy can get going quickly.

Third, strict oversight, transparency, and accountability of all loans made to corporate America. We need oversight. We need transparency. Every loan document will be public and made available to Congress very quickly, so we can see where the money is going, what the terms are, and if it's fair to the American people. And an oversight board, as well as an IG, to make sure things are done on the level.

Fourth, real resources for our state and local governments. That was one of the last decisions we had to make. $150 billion to go to states and localities who are so hard-pressed because of all the new expenses that covid-19 puts upon them—and because they're not getting the resources they usually get, since taxes are delayed until June.

And finally, real, real help for small businesses. My dad was a small businessman, an exterminator. I know how small business people worry and suffer. They will be getting loans. Their employees will be paid by the federal government while they're closed because they don't have customers or services. And they can, too, bounce back afterwards. So this agreement is really an outstanding agreement.

To them, to all Americans I say: help is on the way. Big help and quick help. We're going to take up and pass this package to care for those who are now caring for us, and help carry millions of Americans through these dark economic times. 

###

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
03.24.20

“The American People Need Our Democratic Friends to Take “Yes” for An Answer”

‘If we act today, what Americans will remember, and what history will record, is that the Senate did the right thing. That we came together. That we took a lesson from the way Americans are uniting and working together all across our country. That we combined ideas from both sides and took a bold step to protect Americans and help our nation through a crisis.’

WASHINGTON, D.C.  U.S. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) delivered the following remarks today on the Senate floor regarding the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act:

“For weeks now, the American people have been contending with the coronavirus pandemic that is spreading across our country and the massive disruptions to daily life it is creating. They’re grappling with small business closures, mass layoffs, and uncertainty for their families.

“But that isn’t all. For the last several days now, in the midst of all that, they’ve also had to watch their United States Senate spin its wheels.

“As we convene this morning, roughly 40 percent of our population is under stay-at-home orders from state leaders.

“Employers across America are wondering how they’ll keep the lights on. Doctors, nurses, and healthcare professionals are crying out for support.

“We literally have Army field hospitals on their way to being set up in major American cities.

“In the space of just a few weeks, this has become our “new normal.”

“This is a national crisis. It’s the most serious threat to Americans’ health in over a century, and quite likely the greatest risk to Americans’ jobs and prosperity that we have seen since the Great Depression.

“Hundreds of thousands of Americans have already lost their jobs because so much of our commerce has been put on pause.

“Families are wondering how they are going to pay their rent or mortgage in eight days. Rent is due on April 1st. People don’t know how they’re going to pay bills or make their car payment.

“Many other hardworking Americans are still employed, for now, but fall asleep every night wondering if it will be their turn to wake up to that e-mail or phone call tomorrow.

“American seniors have seen decades of savings cut down in the space of days as the markets tumble.

“Our national life has literally been transformed in less than a month.

“The urgency and the gravity of this moment cannot be lost on anyone.

“Every day — every hour — the Congress delays in passing a significant relief package, we risk more Americans’ livelihoods, and the safety of more healthcare professionals.

“That’s why, right after I fast-tracked the Democratic House’s relief proposal through the Senate, I immediately turned the Senate towards developing an even bigger and bolder relief package for the American people.

“Nine days ago, I laid out the key objectives of our work.

“We had to send direct financial assistance to Americans. We had to help Main Street small businesses. We had to act to stabilize the foundations of our economy for workers. And of course, we had to send more resources to medical professionals and our healthcare system.

“Five days ago, Senate Republicans released our initial framework for the CARES Act.

“We put forward bold policies like sending cash directly to Americans; pouring money into small businesses; lending to national industries to prevent mass layoffs; and surge resources for doctors, nurses, and patients.

“We knew we needed a proposal to address our nation’s pain at literally every level.

“Now, in the past few days, some voices have tried to pit some Americans against other Americans, and argue that directly helping workers and strengthening businesses are somehow conflicting priorities.

“That is utter nonsense. American workers need paychecks. They need jobs.

“The working men and women of this country do need direct relief from government in this crisis — but for goodness sakes, they also need their paychecks.

“They need to be able to resume their lives and their jobs once this is over.

“These two things cannot be separated. There’s a term for when you separate employees from employers. It’s called unemployment. That’s what we are trying to avoid.

“So this is no time to point fingers or stoke culture wars. This is a time to unify.

“Perhaps now more than at any moment in living memory, all of us Americans are in this together.

“This pandemic is not the fault of the American workers who make this country run; it is not the fault of small-business owners; it is not the fault of major national employers.

“Everyone needs help. We are all in this together. We need an all-of-the-above approach. And that’s what our framework put forward.  Help for workers, and families, and employers, and healthcare providers.

“As soon as Republicans put out our draft proposal to treat every aspect of this crisis, I immediately called for bipartisan talks.

“That’s not something you see often in Washington: as soon as I released our first draft, I immediately invited the other side to start changing it! That’s what you call urgency.

“We set up bipartisan working groups. I asked negotiators to work together to turn our rough draft into something that could pass the Senate with overwhelming bipartisan support.

“Republicans and Democrats traded ideas. Democrats asked for many changes to the initial draft, and received many.

“The updated text released a few days ago included proposals from the other side. And of course, as our colleagues have dragged out the last several days, even further changes have been made at their request.

“This majority has gone out of its way to make this process as bipartisan and open as possible. The Administration has bent over backwards to work with Democrats and address their concerns.

“Now, at last, I believe we are on the five-yard line.

“It has taken a lot of noise and rhetoric to get us here. That sometimes happens in this town.

“At different times, we received Democratic counteroffers that demanded things like new emission standards or tax credits for solar panels. We saw the Speaker of the House release an encyclopedia of unrelated demands as though it were a coronavirus proposal.

“Despite of all that, we are very close. We are close to a bill that takes our bold Republican framework, integrates further ideas from both parties, and delivers huge progress on each of the four core priorities I laid out a week ago.

“So today, the Senate can get back on track.

“Today, we can make all of the Washington drama fade away.

“If we act today, what Americans will remember, and what history will record, is that the Senate did the right thing. That we came together. That we took a lesson from the way Americans are uniting and working together all across our country. That we combined ideas from both sides and took a bold step to protect Americans and help our nation through a crisis.

“I’m not sure how many ways to say it but the clock has run out. The buzzer is sounding. The hour for bargaining as though this were business as usual has expired.

“The American people need our Democratic friends to take “yes” for an answer.

“I hope that will happen today. Doctors and nurses need masks. Families need help. Small businesses need cash. Hospitals need funding.

“Their Senate majority is ready to deliver those things. We have been ready to deliver those things for a while.

“I hope today is the day this body will get it done.”


Committtee for a Responsible Federal Budget
March 24, 2020

These Provisions Have No Place in an Emergency Bill 

Read the blog.
Negotiators continue to work on a third response bill to the coronavirus (COVID-19) pandemic, with legislation proposed Monday by House Democrats and last Thursday by Senate Republicans. Both bills include important provisions to strengthen public health, aid those most affected by the crisis, support the economy, and address the current emergency. However, mixed in with these proposals are a number of changes that have little or nothing to do with the crisis at hand. In a statement Sunday, we warned policymakers: "Don't Play Politics with the Coronavirus Response." Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget president Maya MacGuineas said:
 
Preventing a health and economic calamity will require an unprecedented level of spending, but each dollar must still be spent wisely.... Unrelated measures that are tucked into the current bill will compromise its credibility and make it more difficult to pass future response measures as they prove necessary. This is a moment to put special interest politics aside and focus only on the emergency at hand.
 
Unfortunately, policymakers are seeking to include several of these unrelated measures, diverting precious dollars away from where they are needed most.
 
A House-proposed draft circulated Monday includes the following measures that would do little to address or mitigate the crisis:
  • Reduce student loan debt by $10,000 per borrower
  • Permanently expand Affordable Care Act (ACA) premium subsidies
  • Forgive all the U.S. Postal Service's debt
  • Make the Child Tax Credit (CTC) fully refundable for the next 6 years
  • Increase the size of the CTC by $1,600 for children under age 6
  • Bail out multiemployer pension plans that were failing prior to the crisis
  • Temporarily expand dependent care tax breaks
Meanwhile, the Senate-proposed bill released last Thursday includes measures to:
  • Weaken base-broadening enacted in the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), retroactive to 2018, including limits on interest deductibility
  • Enact unrelated technical fixes to the TCJA related to the "retail glitch" and repatriation payment refunds
  • Creating a new $300 above-the-line deduction for charitable giving in 2020
In general, these proposals will do little if anything to address the current crisis. While some are sensible policies on their own, they should be enacted through the regular legislative process and with adequate offsets. They should not be tacked on to emergency legislation, particularly if the measures are permanent or the costs come at the expense of needed emergency spending.
 
Our above list is not exhaustive, and readers should email us other provisions that simply don't belong. Now is not the time to play politics with a national emergency.
Read the blog.

The Concord Coalition
March 24, 2020

Fight the Wolf, Then the Termites

As the nation grapples with devastating healthcare and economic consequences of the spreading COVID-19 pandemic, policymakers in Washington have been ratcheting-up their responses. Bills and proposals have included actions to fight the virus, maintain employment and stimulate the economy. Given the unique nature of the crisis we are facing, vigorous efforts are needed on all these fronts.

To be effective, fiscal responses to the COVID-19 pandemic should be timely (get the money out fast), targeted (get the money to those who need it most) and temporary (permanent changes to spending and tax policy can wait). They should also be large enough to have an impact. While the costs will be substantial ($2 trillion at least), and will inevitably result in a major spike in the debt, this concern must take a back seat for now to protecting the nation’s physical and economic health.

The first thing to recognize about the current situation is that the developing economic downturn, almost certain to become a recession, is a direct and necessary result of fighting the virus. Stay at home orders, closed businesses, cancelled events and postponed travel are all part of an effort to limit the scope of the healthcare damage by limiting daily routine commerce. Economic assistance, no matter how broad or how deep will be an ineffective bottomless pit unless the spread of COVID-19 is brought under control.

The second thing to recognize is the enormity of the economic hit that will come from deliberately shutting down the economy for an indefinite period. Second quarter gross domestic product (GDP) could plunge by as much as 24 percent according to Goldman Sachs. This would be much larger than the 8.4 percent quarterly drop at the height of the Great Recession in 2008 or the 6.1 percent drop during the 1982 recession. It goes well beyond what can be treated with traditional economic stimulus. It will require a major and immediate infusion of cash just to stabilize the economy. 

The main concern is to maintain cash flows for employers, states, families and individuals in the face of efforts to keep people at home and close non-essential businesses. As income plummets, businesses will face insolvency through no fault of their own, layoffs will surge,”gig” workers will go broke and states will run through available cash. Making sure that businesses can stay afloat and that individuals can pay their essential bills such as rent, mortgages, healthcare, food and utilities is necessary to prevent a much deeper economic problem.  

As we begin to emerge from the crisis, traditional economic stimulus may be needed to coax Americans out of their self-isolation and encourage businesses to ramp-up operations. In the meantime, direct payments to those most in need can help limit the damage and better position the economy for a rebound.  

The nation will recover from this pandemic. The sooner we stop the spread of the virus, the sooner that will happen. When it does, policymakers will need to turn their attention to the fiscal fallout. We will have a much larger debt but more importantly we will still have the pre-existing condition of an unsustainable gap between routine spending and tax policies. The latest projection from the Congressional Budget Office (CBO), which was issued on March 19th, showed a $13.1 trillion increase in debt held by the public over the next 10 years with the annual deficit reaching $1.8 trillion (5.5 percent of GDP) by 2020. That is why it’s important for the pandemic response to be aggressive but “temporary” in the sense that it does not make the pre-existing structural fiscal gap even worse.

It is sometimes said that the deficit is more like having termites in the basement rather than a wolf at the door. Right now we have both. First, get rid of the wolf. Then fight the termites.
 
Robert Bixby
Executive Director, The Concord Coalition
Republican National Committee
March 24, 2020
email from Steve Guest.  subject: Dems put politics over people

Reminder: Democrats have blocked the coronavirus relief package because Nancy Pelosi wants to use the bill to advance her radical agenda.
 
See below for examples of some of the items Pelosi has stuffed into her legislation that have nothing to do with coronavirus relief:
 
 
Meanwhile, new Gallup polling shows the American people know who is working for them: President Trump. 60% approve of President Trump’s response to the coronavirus.
 
But on the other end of Pennsylvania Ave, Pelosi has prioritized far left policies over and above helping American workers who are affected by coronavirus.
 
Bottom Line: Democrats fully embraced the mantra “Never allow a crisis to go to waste.” In this instance, Democrats are using a pandemic to push a radical agenda.
 
 
Steve Guest
Rapid Response Director
Republican National Committee

Republican National Committee
March 23, 2020
email from Steve Guest.  subject: Dems use coronavirus to advance their radical agenda

We now know why Democrats on the hill blocked the coronavirus stimulus package from moving forward: they want to use is as a vehicle to ram through their far left agenda.
 
At least House Minority Whip James Clyburn doesn’t hide it when he said, “This is a tremendous opportunity to restructure things to fit our vision.”
 
Democrats see coronavirus as an opportunity to get “unprecedented collective bargaining powers for unions,” “increased fuel emissions standards for airlines,” and an “expansion of wind and solar tax credits” passed.
 
Unbelievable. Democrats are going to let the American people continue to suffer while they try to take advantage of this pandemic for their own agenda.

 

Meanwhile, this morning the Democrat Party’s frontrunner Joe Biden couldn’t even get through a 15 minute speech without it going off the rails: Biden confused who the governor of Massachusetts is and panicked when there was a teleprompter malfunction
 
Despite that, Biden still pushed falsehoods about President Trump’s response. Click here for a thorough time line of President Trump’s response and click here for a time line of China’s lies about coronavirus. 
 
Furthermore, Biden and Obama are the reason N95 masks were depleted from the national stockpile. Despite the recommendation to replenish the mask stockpile, they never did.
Biden for President
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
March 22, 2020

Statement from Vice President Joe Biden on Congressional Economic Stimulus Negotiations

It's simple: President Trump and Mitch McConnell are trying to put corporate bailouts ahead of families. And it's simply wrong.
 
Here's what's happening. The White House and the Senate Republicans have proposed a $500 billion slush fund for corporations, with almost no conditions. Donald Trump's Treasury Secretary would decide which big businesses get how much, and he can give out billions with virtually no strings attached. The Trump Administration could even allow companies to use taxpayers’ money for stock buybacks and executive pay packages, and they don’t have to tell Americans where the money is going for months. 
 
This is par for the course for this president. We have just watched too many CEOs spend the last few years squandering the massive Trump corporate tax cuts on buying back their own stock and increasing their own compensation, rather than investing in their workers or making their businesses more sustainable. No more blank checks to corporations. Any lifelines to big companies should ensure the aid lifts up workers, instead of enriching CEOs or shareholders. If these companies are taking money from taxpayers, they must make an enforceable commitment that they will keep workers on payroll.
 
We can’t let Donald Trump and Mitch McConnell hold small businesses, workers, and communities hostage until they get their no-strings corporate bailout. McConnell should immediately allow a bipartisan vote on aggressive measures to help small businesses, workers, and communities first, so the relief they need can get moving. 
 
To make matters worse, as they carry water for corporate America, President Trump and Mitch McConnell are refusing to give states and communities on the front lines the help they need to deal with the crisis they are facing. They are refusing to provide sufficient, sustainable relief to workers. They are denying millions the emergency paid leave they deserve to help keep families safe. They are refusing to forgive a minimum of $10,000 of student debt per person. They are refusing to increase Social Security benefits for our seniors and people with disabilities. They are refusing to provide enough health coverage or Medicaid funding during a public health emergency. And they are refusing to take the necessary steps to ensure food and nutrition for vulnerable families or to prevent these families from losing their homes.
 
This is a time to help families, communities, and small businesses. The people trying to pay mortgages and rent, student loans and urgent bills — they need help and they shouldn’t have to pay for a corporate handout before they get it. The family-run restaurant that is trying to stay open and pay its workers — they need a lifeline. The worker who is losing hours and therefore losing wages — they need to be made whole. The family that will go hungry tonight — they need food on the table. Those losing jobs — they need strong, sustained unemployment benefits whether they are a gig worker or a full-time employee. Social Security checks need to be boosted. Student debt should be forgiven. Cash relief needs to go out fast to all of the people who need it the most.
 
These are the hardworking, struggling Americans who should come first — not the big corporations looking for a blank check. That’s not only good economics. That’s who we are as Americans — we lend a hand to help each other, we step up when hard times fall. We all deserve leadership that does the same.

###

Bernie 2020
March 22, 2020

NEWS: Sanders Calls on Congress to Stand Up to Corporate Greed

BURLINGTON, Vt. – Sen. Bernie Sanders on Sunday issued the following statement as corporate lobbyists worked to influence negotiations over the coronavirus spending package:

“As hundreds and thousands of Americans are being laid off and losing their health insurance, it is absolutely unacceptable that lobbyists are working behind closed doors with Mitch McConnell on legislation that may end up providing hundreds of billions of dollars in corporate welfare to wealthy campaign contributors and profitable corporations.

“Just in the last few days, we’ve seen numerous examples of lobbyists and their agents fighting for special favors: the airline industry is asking for $50 billion, the private space industry is asking for $5 billion, the hotel industry wants $150 billion, the National Association of Manufacturers wants $1.4 trillion, the International Council of Shopping Centers wants a guarantee of up to $1 trillion, Adidas wants to sneak in a long-sought provision allowing people to use pretax money to pay for gym memberships and fitness equipment - even when many gyms and retail stores are closed nationwide, and corporate pork producers are using the coronavirus to push Congress to expedite guest worker visas, even at a time when international travel and immigration is largely shut down.

“Now is not the time to allow large corporations to take advantage of this horrific crisis by ripping off U.S. taxpayers and profiteering off of the pandemic.

“We cannot be providing hundreds of billions in corporate welfare to benefit CEOs and wealthy stockholders. No, Jeff Bezos and his billionaire friends do not need a special $5 billion bailout package for private space travel.  No, we do not need to hand out hundreds of millions to the Mars Candy Bar family and their industry.  No, we cannot give Trump’s Treasury Department a blank check and free rein to bail out the airlines, cruise ships, hotels, and many other industries, while providing next to nothing to help the homeless or the most vulnerable people in this country.

“In this time of unprecedented crisis, we need an unprecedented legislative response that focuses on the emergency health care needs of the American people and that puts working families and the poor ahead of CEOs and huge corporations.”
 
###

Libertarian Party
For Immediate Release:
03.23.2020

Libertarian Party Press Release on Congressional Paralysis

The Libertarian Party calls on the Republicans and Democrats to become aware of the tremendous changes Americans are dealing with in their lives, and to make a similar change in the way Congress operates.

Firstly, it is critical that Congress allow remote voting immediately. In the absence of a functioning congress, the Executive branch has too much power. With members of both the House and Senate stricken, the need is urgent and logical. There are no technical issues that could not be overcome.

Secondly, Congress must put aside it’s constant game of position and opposition and recognize when they put things into bills that their opponents cannot live with, that they are hurting the American people. Of course as Libertarians we’d prefer Congress stimulate the economy by removing regulations. We’d prefer Americans be given more money by telling them there’s no income tax this year. And we’d prefer the government completely get out of the process of handling the medical response, and let doctors and health care companies operate freely.

The Libertarian Party however recognizes that we cannot get the legislation we want passed in this political environment. And Republicans and Democrats must recognize the same political reality. Republicans and Democrats should meet with their separate bills, and then give the opposition a “line item veto” to reject the things they cannot live with.

It is clear that a majority of lawmakers of both parties and a majority of Americans support an emergency payment to every adult and extending the deadline for filing income taxes. Bringing a clean bill that did only those things to a vote would provide emergency relief to people, not bailouts to politically connected industries.

Whatever remains is the bill that can be passed today. It’s unclear what the best path forward is because our situation is changing daily. Yet Congress is in a unique situation where they can model a behavior they would like the citizens to repeat. When you cannot see how to get to the end of a problem, do the next right thing. A unified Congress passing the smaller things they can agree upon would be a message to the country that though we may not know how this will all turn out -- we can make progress towards making things better.

The Libertarian Party calls on Republicans and Democrats to put aside the leveraging of the crisis for political gain, and to, for the sake of the American people, find the things they can agree upon and pass them immediately. The country doesn’t need monolithic legislation because the people know that nothing is going to be solved overnight. The people need to see that progress is being made. And the people should rightly despise the villains who absent getting their politically divisive agenda passed, will block any other legislation that will provide relief.

Daniel Fishman
Executive Director
The Libertarian National Committee


Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer
March 22, 2020

Schumer Floor Remarks Providing Update on Coronavirus Legislative Response Negotiations and Outlining Democratic Priorities that Put Workers and People First

Washington, D.C. – U.S. Senator Chuck Schumer today spoke on the Senate floor to outline Democratic priorities during ongoing negotiations for Phase 3 Coronavirus response legislation. Below are Senator Schumer’s remarks, which can also be viewed here:

I want to provide everyone with an update about the status of negotiations on the third phase of coronavirus legislation. Early this morning, Leader McConnell presented to us a highly partisan bill, written exclusively by Republicans, and he said he would call a vote to proceed to it today.

So who is being partisan? He knows darn well that for this bill to pass, it needs both Democratic and Republican support. And furthermore, when Speaker Pelosi and I said, “Let’s have a four corner negotiation,” it was Leader McConnell who resisted. So whatever we do here in the Senate, the House is doing its own bill. It made no sense then, it makes no sense now. I said to the Leader then, that would slow things down. So that’s where we are.

Most important is the legislation itself. The legislation has many problems. At the top of the list, it included a large corporate bailout with no protections for workers and virtually no oversight. Also very troubling, the bill had significant shortfalls of money that our hospitals, states, cities, and medical workers desperately needed. This is a public health crisis, it is inexplicable to skimp on funding to address the pandemic.

I told both Leader McConnell and Secretary Mnuchin that our caucus could not support such a partisan bill and urged Leader McConnell to delay the 3 p.m. vote so that we might come to a bipartisan agreement. I’m glad he agreed because Democrats want to move forward with a bipartisan agreement.

Unfortunately, the legislation has not improved enough in the past three hours to earn the necessary votes to proceed. Given more time, I believe we could reach a point where the legislation is close enough to what the nation needs, for all Senators—all Senators—to want to move forward. We are not yet at that point.

America needs a Marshall Plan for our hospitals and public health infrastructure. The bill should include much more money for hospitals, community health centers, nursing homes, and enough funding to address the coming shortages in masks, ICU beds, ventilators, testing and personal protective equipment.

This bill needs much more money to offset the costs now being incurred by state and local governments who are propping up their health networks. We cannot reach a point where our states and localities are going bankrupt or firing public employees like teachers and first responders.
And the corporate bailout provisions remain unacceptable. If we’re going to provide assistance to certain industries, there must be more oversight, transparency, and accountability. And there must certainly be protections for workers.

On unemployment insurance, we’re glad the bill has moved in the direction we outlined, but at the moment, the expanded unemployment benefits we’ve fought for last only three months. It’s supposed to be longer. We need it to be longer.

Now, let me be clear: the Majority Leader was well aware of how this vote would go before it happened, but he chose to move forward with it anyway, even though negotiations are continuing. So who’s playing games?

But our caucus is united in trying to deliver a bill that addresses this health and economic crisis quickly and we’re committed to working in a bipartisan way to get it done, both sides of the aisle voting for a bill.

We are entitling our proposal—the Democratic bill that we introduced—“Workers First,” and we intend to follow through on this principle as we negotiate.

Now, the bipartisan negotiations on this package continue, even as we speak. Secretary Mnuchin was in my office just about a half hour ago. Changes to the legislation are being made, even as we speak. The bill can, and must, continue to improve.

We’re closer than we’ve been at any time over the past forty-eight hours to an agreement, but there are still too many problems in the proposed legislation.

Can we overcome the remaining disagreements in the next twenty-four hours? Yes. We can and we should. The nation demands it.

###
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY)
03.19.20

McConnell Introduces the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act

‘I am officially introducing the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act… I hope this bold new proposal will find a similar degree of bipartisan respect and mutual urgency on the other side of the aisle, and across the Capitol. I look forward to working with our Democratic colleagues and the Administration to complete this important work and deliver for the country.’

WASHINGTON, D.C.  U.S. Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-KY) delivered the following remarks today on the Senate floor regarding the CARES Act:

“As our nation confronts this health crisis and the economic crisis it is spawning, Senate Republicans have prepared a bold legislative proposal.

“I am officially introducing the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act.

“This legislation takes bold action on four major priorities that are extremely urgent and extremely necessary: 
  1. Direct financial help for the American people;
  2. Rapid relief for small businesses and their employees;
  3. Significant steps to stabilize our economy and protect jobs;
  4. And, of course, more support for the brave healthcare professionals and the patients who are fighting the coronavirus on the front lines.
“Now, just yesterday, by an overwhelming vote, the Senate passed bipartisan legislation that originated with the Democratic House of Representatives.

“So I hope this bold new proposal will find a similar degree of bipartisan respect and mutual urgency on the other side of the aisle, and across the Capitol.

“I look forward to working with our Democratic colleagues and the Administration to complete this important work and deliver for the country.

“Here are the next steps. A group of my Republican colleagues are standing by to explain this legislation and talk with their counterparts: Chairman Crapo and Senator Toomey from the Banking Committee; Chairman Alexander from the HELP Committee; Chairman Grassley and Senator Portman from the Finance Committee; Chairman Rubio from the Small Business Committee, as well as Senator Collins; Chairman Wicker from the Commerce Committee; And Senator Thune, our Majority Whip.

“These will be our point people. I invite all of their Democratic counterparts to join us at the table right away.

“These are urgent discussions and they need to happen at a member level, starting now.

“I might add, all Republicans senators, whether they are a part of this group I just mentioned or not, have been asked to stay in town. We’re here, and we are ready to act as soon as an agreement with our colleagues across the aisle can be reached.

“The Administration has agreed to send the Secretary of Treasury, the Director of the National Economic Council, and the White House Director of Legislative Affairs.

“These bipartisan discussions must begin immediately and continue with urgency, at the member level, until we have results.

“We know this legislation will not be the last word.

“Bipartisan, bicameral talks are already underway to act on the Administration’s request for supplemental appropriations.

“But we need to take bold and swift action as soon as possible.

“We need to take further steps to continue addressing our nation’s healthcare needs…

“And we need to help protect American workers, families, and small businesses from this unique economic crisis that threatens to worsen with every day. We need to have the American people’s backs.

“This legislation is a significant next step.

“And the Senate is not going anywhere until we take action."

Preview YouTube video Connie: "I want someone who's honest